Chadema national chairman, Tundu Lissu, has told the High Court that the treason case against him is based on speculation that he threatened the government, arguing that the prosecution has failed to establish the legal basis for the charge. Defending himself, Mr Lissu submitted as he continued his final arguments before Justices Dunstan Ndunguru, James Karayemaha and Ferdinand Kiwonde.
He faces a treason charge under Section 39(2)(d) of the Penal Code (2022 Revision), with the prosecution alleging that on April 3, 2025, he acted with seditious intent to incite the public to prevent the 2025 General Election by making and publishing statements online.
Mr Lissu identified nine issues for the court to determine, beginning with what he described as a legal defect in the charge sheet.
He argued that Section 39(2)(d) does not criminalise an intention to mobilise ‘the public’, but refers to ‘a person or group of people’, making the wording too broad to give him adequate notice.
"I have been prosecuted because of speculation and the law does not permit speculative charges. In these circumstances, My Lords, the correct answer cannot be anything other than no. This means the accused did not form any intent to persuade a person or group of people to prevent the 2025 General Election for the purpose of threatening the government of the United Republic of Tanzania," submitted Mr Lissu.
He challenged the prosecution's interpretation that threatening to disrupt an election necessarily amounts to threatening the government because elections are conducted under laws overseen by the State.
He attributed that reasoning to the first prosecution witness, Senior Assistant Commissioner of Police (ACP) George Bagyem.
To challenge that premise, Mr Lissu cited laws administered by different constitutional bodies, including legislation governing the Judiciary and Parliament. He said the Presidential, Parliamentary and Local Government Elections Act, 2024, and the Electoral Code of Ethics govern electoral matters, which fall under the Electoral Commission rather than the Executive.
He also cited judicial precedents, arguing that criminal guilt cannot be established through speculation.
He noted that treason is the only constitutional offence punishable by death. "Therefore, those who prosecuted me want me hanged simply on speculation that I threatened the government. On these legal grounds, My Lords, I pray you do not accept their call, wanting me sentenced to death merely because they feel I threatened the government," insisted Mr Lissu.
On the prosecution evidence, Mr Lissu said only four of the 17 witnesses addressed the incitement allegation: ACP Bagyem, John Kaaya, ACP Amini Mahamba and an undercover civilian journalist, identified as PW17.
He argued that the three police officers were not at the meeting and relied on online material. "My Lords, PW17 (the 17th prosecution witness) is the only witness who is an eyewitness, the only witness who saw and heard because he was present at the meeting while the rest is just hearsay from online," explained Mr Lissu.
"And that PW17 did not only see and heard but he is also the one who broadcast the event; he is a journalist," added Mr Lissu.
He said PW17 confirmed that the meeting was held to explain Chadema's "No reforms, no election" position to election aspirants. During cross-examination, the witness acknowledged that he had seen nothing treasonous and did not consider Mr Lissu's words an offence.
"PW17, My Lords, is not my witness; he is a witness of those who want to see me sentenced to hang; there is no treason," declared Mr Lissu. "The 17th witness is a great witness because he was present, saw, and heard. I have been in jail while the Prosecution had this evidence. If I do not speak about this, My Lords, the stones will speak," said Mr Lissu.
"My Lords, on this, the prosecution witnesses' evidence contradicts each other; it means all the prosecution's evidence on this issue is completely untrustworthy," he added.
Mr Lissu further argued that his defence testimony showed that his remarks were intended to encourage aspirants to boycott the election until democratic reforms were achieved, rather than incite violence.
He said the prosecution did not cross-examine him on his intention or the meeting's purpose.
Citing Court of Appeal decisions in Justice Katiti, Nyerere Nyague and Choha Samson @ Kibiriti, he argued that failure to cross-examine a witness on a material point amounts to acceptance of that evidence.
"My Lords, the prosecution's failure to cross-examine me regarding the purpose of that meeting and the intention of my words means they cannot say they do not accept that intention; they have accepted it," argued Mr Lissu.
He said defence witnesses John Mnyika (DW2), Amani Golugwa (DW3), Brenda Rupia (DW4) and John Heche (DW5), whose accounts of the meeting’s peaceful purpose were not challenged by the prosecution during cross-examination, supported the same position.



